Blog

Introduction:
As the world grapples with the realities of climate change, governments and financial institutions are taking proactive measures to assess and manage climate-related financial risks. The U.S. Federal Reserve, in its commitment to ensure financial stability, launched a pilot Climate Scenario Analysis (CSA) exercise in January 2023. This initiative aims to enhance the ability of both large banking organizations and supervisors to identify, measure, monitor, and manage climate-related financial risks. In this blog, we delve into the details of this pioneering exercise, its objectives, participant banks, and its potential impact on the financial sector.

About the Pilot Climate Scenario Analysis (CSA) Exercise:
The Federal Reserve’s pilot CSA exercise seeks to gather qualitative and quantitative information from six of the nation’s largest banks: Bank of America, Citigroup, Goldman Sachs, JPMorgan Chase, Morgan Stanley, and Wells Fargo. The exercise’s primary objective is to gain insights into the climate risk-management practices and challenges faced by these large banking organizations. By engaging with participants, the Federal Reserve aims to understand their approaches, methodologies, data challenges, and potential impact estimates concerning climate-related financial risks.

The exercise entails detailed documentation of governance and risk-management practices, measurement techniques, and lessons learned from the process. The ultimate goal is to enhance the capability of both banks and supervisors to navigate climate-related financial risks effectively.

Current Approaches of Banks to Managing Climate-Related Financial Risks:
The participating banks are required to provide credit-risk projections and respond to qualitative questions about their governance and risk management practices related to climate risks. While these banks have developed environmental credit policies concerning industries like oil and gas and power utilities, they are at different stages in adopting climate-risk measurement approaches.

For instance, Wells Fargo employs climate scenario analysis to establish net-zero targets for 2050 and 2030 sector targets. Bank of America and Citigroup are integrating climate scenario analysis results into their risk management and capital planning processes. This variance in approaches highlights the evolving nature of climate risk management across the financial sector.

Working of the Pilot CSA Program:
The pilot CSA exercise is designed to assess both physical and transition climate risks. For physical risks, the banks will analyze how their real estate portfolios would perform under various hurricane scenarios. Additionally, banks will design and test climate “hazard” scenarios in regions where they have significant real estate exposure. These scenarios will evaluate the potential impact with or without insurance coverage.

Transition risks, on the other hand, involve scenarios where governments either fail to adopt additional climate policies or successfully implement stringent climate policies and innovation. These scenarios will be tested against the banks’ commercial real estate and corporate loan portfolios over the next decade.

The pilot CSA program will culminate in the banks calculating and reporting a range of outcomes, including the likelihood of loan defaults, associated costs, and the overall impact on borrowers’ risk. The banks will also share qualitative insights about risk management practices, methodologies, specific results, and lessons learned.

Future Implications:
While the pilot CSA exercise is set to conclude by the end of 2023, its implications reach beyond its immediate duration. The data and insights gathered from this exercise could potentially inform future programs and efforts to address climate-related financial risks. By actively engaging banks and supervisors, the Federal Reserve is fostering a collective effort towards building a resilient financial sector that is better equipped to handle climate-related challenges.

Conclusion:
The Federal Reserve’s pilot Climate Scenario Analysis exercise is a pivotal step towards integrating climate risk management into the financial sector’s operations. By collaborating with large banking organizations, the initiative aims to enhance the understanding, measurement, and management of climate-related financial risks. As the financial landscape continues to evolve in the face of climate change, the lessons learned and practices developed through this exercise are expected to contribute significantly to a more sustainable and resilient global economy.

Source: